Since her precocious debut in the 1990’s in Les Misérables and My Fair Lady, Melissa is known for her silvery voice and incandescent stage presenc
Off-Broadway, her most famous performances include her turn as Dot, opposite Raúl Esparza, in Sunday in The Park with George at the Sondheim Festival at the Kennedy Center in 2004 and her subsequent appearances in the Sondheim musicals Passion in 2
Recent Sondheim performances include playing The Baker’s Wife in three concert performances of Into the Woods. At the Irish Repertory Theatre–which Terry Teachout has called “the finest Off-Broadway theater in New York”–she has starred in eight shows including revivals of Finian’s Rainbow and On A Clear Day You Can See Forever which led The New York Times to say that, “any chance to hear Melissa Errico sing is a chance worth taking,” and The Wall Street Journal to declare that, “no show in which the irresistible Ms. Errico appears could ever be anything but worth seeing.”
Non-musical roles include appearances in George Bernard Shaw and Oscar Wilde, under the direction of Tony Walton, and in Wallace Shawn’s Aunt Dan and Lemon, a role she reprised in a remote production just this year. For her work in the theater, Melissa was recently honored with the Broadway equivalent of a star on Hollywood’s Walk of Fame: a caricature at Sardi’s, celebrating her life on stage.
2023
Dear Liar
Mrs. Patrick Campbell
Irish Repertory Theatre – New York, NY
2018
On A Clear Day You Can See Forever
Daisy Gamble
Irish Repertory Theatre – New York, NY
2016
Finian’s Rainbow
Sharon
Irish Repertory Theatre – New York, NY
2016
Do I Hear a Waltz?
Leona Samish
New York City Center Encores! – New York, NY
2014
Bill Durham
Annie Savoy
Alliance Theater at the Woodruff – Atlanta, GA
2013
2014
More Between Heaven & Earth
Maria Cosway
Salon Sanctuary – New York, NY
American Philosophical Society – Philadelphia, PA
2013
Passion
Clara
Classic Stage Company – New York, NY
2012
Oliver!
Nancy
Irish Repertory Theatre – New York, NY
2010
Candida
Candida
Irish Repertory Theatre – New York
2009-2010
Irving Berlin’s White Christmas
Betty Haynes
Marquis Theatre – New York, NY
2011
2005
Camelot
Guenevere
Irish Repertory Theatre – New York, NY
Los Angeles Hollywood Bowl – Los Angeles, CA
2004-2005
Dracula
Mina Harker
The Belasco Theatre – New York, NY
2004
Finian’s Rainbow
Sharon
Irish Repertory Theatre – New York, NY
2003-2004
Aunt Dan and Lemon
Mother
Theatre Row – New York, NY
2003
My Fair Lady
Eliza Doolittle
Los Angeles Hollywood Bowl – Los Angeles, CA
2003
Threepenny Opera
Polly Peachum
Williamston Theatre Festival – Williamstown, MA
2002
Sunday in the Park with George
Dot
Kennedy Center’s Sondheim Celebration – DC
2002
Amour
Isabelle
Music Box Theatre – New York, NY
1998
High Society
Tracy Samantha Lord
St. James Theatre – New York, NY
1997-1998
Major Barbara
Barbara Undershaft
Irish Repertory Theatre – New York, NY
1996
The Importance of Being Earnest
Gwendolyn
Irish Repertory Theatre – New York, NY
1996
One Touch of Venus
Venus
New York City Center Encores! – New York, NY
1993-1994
My Fair Lady
Eliza Doolittle
Virginia Theatre – New York, NY
1992
Anna Karenina
Princess Kitty Scherbatsky
Circle in the Square Theatre – New York, NY
Les Miserables
Cosette
National Tour