Melissa has gratefully received many awards and nominations for both singing and non-singing roles, including a Tony Award nomination and six Drama Desk Award nominations. She has gone on to have a rich and varied career, having starred in seven Broadway shows: Anna Karenina, the 1993 revival of My Fair Lady in which she played Eliza Doolittle (The New York Times called her “beguiling.”), High Society, Amour (Tony nomination for Best Leading Actress in a Musical), Dracula, the Musical and Irving Berlin’s White Christmas. She has also performed at some of New York City’s most premier off-Broadway stages in musical and non-musical roles. This includes Irish Repertory Theatre where she has starred in Finian’s Rainbow twice as Sharon, earning rave reviews for both portrayals. As a member of Irish Rep. she has also starred in such classic plays as Oscar Wilde’s The Importance of Being Earnest and George Bernard Shaw’s Major Barbara.
She’s had thrilling highs at City Center’s Encores! series, most notably Call Me Madam, One Touch of Venus which nearly set Manhattan on fire, and more recently Do I Hear a Waltz? in 2016. Her continued work with Stephen Sondheim includes starring in Sunday in The Park with George at The Kennedy Center with Raul Esparza and starring as Clara in the first NY revival of Stephen Sondheim’s Passion at The Classic Stage Company in 2013, directed by John Doyle. She won unanimous raves in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, and more leading publications (“Melissa Errico, as Clara, suggests subtle ripples of deeper feeling behind her golden gown and silvery soprano.” – Time Out), as well as being nominated for a 2013 Drama Desk Award.
She has also become a favorite at The Hollywood Bowl in Los Angeles where she starred in My Fair Lady (opposite John Lithgow), Camelot (opposite Jeremy Irons), and The Sound of Music (with a cast led by Marni Nixon and John Schneider), singing for 20,000 people a night for a week! Jeremy Irons and Melissa reprised their Camelot again in 2010 on Broadway’s Shubert Theatre.
Throughout 2017 and into 2018, Melissa performed successful and extended runs at Feinstein’s/54 Below of her solo concert “Melissa Sings Sondheim” celebrating the music of Stephen Sondheim and won raves when she brought it to London’s ‘Live at The Zedel’ for her sold-out UK concert debut co-written with Adam Gopnik. This summer, she will bring her Sondheim program to The Ravinia Festival and will appear for a few nights at Feinstein’s/54 Below in August and for her new Sondheim CD release in November 2018. She is currently starring as Daisy Gamble in the New York Irish Rep. Off-Broadway revival of On A Clear Day You Can See Forever.